11 Comments
User's avatar
Currently known as Simon's avatar

Sounds like you have your cranky pants on JB.... its just bread. I prefer to tear mine into chunks and use the base as a trencher for roast boar with a side of ocelot noses

Expand full comment
Naut's avatar

I just use a mitre box

Expand full comment
Damo's avatar

Perhaps Emily normally uses a two-handed grip, hacking at the bread in the manner of an inexpert headsman?

Expand full comment
dweeze's avatar

But what if you have one of those square-in-profile pan cooked loaves? Stable whichever way you rest it. Preferably white over-processed yeast bread - it suits shallow thinkers.

Tbh, I've moved to using a sharp non-serrated knife for the robust, hearty sourdoughs I'm banging out of late. I get a cleaner cut, less mess and less crush.

Expand full comment
Dave W's avatar

I'm with you JB, it's not brain surgery (unless one trepans along the side too). I admit, I learnt it after a period of being a dull-witted traditionalist. But I've not looked back.

Cutting bread is also the only reason a serrated knife exists in my kitchen.

Expand full comment
insomniac's avatar

I agree in principle with your serrated knife rule, but we do have a small serrated knife called Bluey who is a dab hand at slicing ripe tomatoes.

Expand full comment
Bangar's avatar

Sharpen your knives or get a ceramic blade

Expand full comment
Andrew Reilly's avatar

Apple's news feed give you "one weird trick" articles from non-news sources? That's a compelling argument to continue to have nothing to do with it...

But to humour the substance of this post: I count myself among the stable-base bread cutters, mostly because I don't want to squash or tear it, but also because I like a bit of diagonal on my slices, to make them longer than they would be cut straight across.

So: what's the skinny: why is cutting bread sideways "better" than the other way?

Expand full comment
Damo's avatar

squashes the bread less

Expand full comment
Andrew Reilly's avatar

Never noticed my bread squashed at all. Must only apply to those who cut it with the butter knife.

Learn something new every day. In this case just reinforcing the certainty that other people do things differently...

Expand full comment
Damo's avatar

Disagreement? I'm being silenced! SILENCED!

Expand full comment