28 Comments
User's avatar
Elana Mitchell's avatar

I have seen very mixed reviews about Napoleon, but I must put my history nerd hat on and give it a go. I've started Masters of the Air and am hooked.

Speaking of history nerd, is anyone watching Shogun on Disney?

Expand full comment
Michael Barnes's avatar

Waiting until full season drops, but it is on my to watch list

Expand full comment
Elana Mitchell's avatar

I think you'll love it. I made the mistake of going "I'll have a look and see what it's like" and now I'm stuck on the agony of the weekly episode drop 😂

Expand full comment
Michael Barnes's avatar

a salutary lesson for all of us

Expand full comment
Elana Mitchell's avatar

Quite! Cats and curiosity etc 🤷‍♀️

Expand full comment
Dirk's avatar

RE Shogun: hai!

Expand full comment
Elana Mitchell's avatar

Woot! What are your thoughts? 🤩

Expand full comment
Dirk's avatar

Having read the book and seen the original 1980s series, and now this one. Ok nobody beats Mifune (though Hiroyuki Sanada does a fine job) and the 80s Maurice Jarre soundtrack is also not beaten. But this version is more gritty and more explicit and detailed. Mariko san is a bad ass instead of a passive submissive doll. So as a series definitely one to watch.

2024 turns out to be a great series year: Masters, Shogun, The Regime (with Kate Winslet), The New Look (a great period piece on post WW2 France) and season 2 of Tokyo Vice. All we are missing is the Axis of Time season 1 (and the overpaid but way too late cameo of yours truly off course ;-) )

Expand full comment
Elana Mitchell's avatar

I’ve been waiting eagerly for the Regime, and The New Look is on my watchlist 😍

Expand full comment
Bill H's avatar

Eh check out Dune. Fucking awesome

Expand full comment
Andrew Reilly's avatar

Yeah. How can you make a three hour movie that has you leaving the theatre thinking "that ended a bit abruptly: I want some more, please."

Expand full comment
Bill H's avatar

Translating a great book into a great movie is rare. Made me remember why going to the movies was fun .

Expand full comment
Dave W's avatar

For me it's so rare that I actively avoid adaptations of books that I've loved. I'll make an exception for JB on the presumption that it'll put more money in his pocket and that the 'splosions will be FKN AWESOME!1!

Expand full comment
Bill H's avatar

Ya for sure. If the Cruel Stars isn’t streaming on Amazon or HBO or wherever soon I say we protest at the UN !

Expand full comment
Bill H's avatar

BTW IMAX is the only way to go on Dune

Expand full comment
John Birmingham's avatar

Or Apple Vision Motherfucking PRO!!!

Expand full comment
Bill H's avatar

But I can’t bring my wife . A truly reluctant sci fi fan who loved it . Not to mention the giant tub of movie popcorn that I paid a kings ransom for.

Expand full comment
w from brisbane's avatar

Here’s a chance to fight back against the mysterious gremlin that disappeared your beloved fleece-lined bomber jacket.

I see that you can purchase Joaquin Phoenix’s 2023 Napoleon long wool coat for $149.99 USD (reduced from $199.99!) right now on the internet!!

Expand full comment
John Birmingham's avatar

Oh. My. God. OMIGOD OMIGOD OMIGOD

Expand full comment
Bangar's avatar

I'd prefer my great coat

Expand full comment
w from brisbane's avatar

I’m sure it’s a great coat. Further investigation indicates the Napoleon coat website is pretty shonky so sadly I would probably look elsewhere to buy my murderous 17th Century despot gear.

Expand full comment
John Birmingham's avatar

Damn

Expand full comment
w from brisbane's avatar

Oops, 19th century.

Expand full comment
Dave W's avatar

I understand that Perfidious Albion was always perfidious because their interest in the continent from 1700 or so was in maintaining the status quo, such that none of the European powers could threaten Britain.

The development of Germany as a power in its own right, as opposed to 400 or so bizarre little kingdoms, was a factor in upsetting the status quo, and then the long, slow, decline of the Holy Roman Empire (those jut-jawed Hapsburgs) was a mess too. So the Brits were continually playing the major players against each other, to ensure that none of them could threaten Britain's naval power and international empire.

Or we could just watch Game of Thrones for the fictionalised version with dragons.

Expand full comment
John Birmingham's avatar

My favorite part of the Napoleon movie, is when the little Corsican thug roars at the British, Ambassador, “You think you are so special, because you have BOATS!“

Expand full comment
cgumm's avatar

The sex scenes were a lot of fun...

Expand full comment
Michael Barnes's avatar

in Dune or Napoleon?

Expand full comment
cgumm's avatar

haha Napoleon

Expand full comment