Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Naut's avatar

Huh?

Expand full comment
Tim Allen's avatar

Well since you've explicitly invited a thorough nitpicking 😂, I'll have a go - though more along the lines of other stuff you arguably should mention, rather than stuff that is wrong. The pair of protostars you mention is fusing hydrogen to helium. That's the usual thing for stars to do, so all good so far. However, fusing hydrogen isn't all they do. The fact that we live on a chunk of rock is proof of this. As stars get older they start to take on more and more ambitious fusion projects, ie fusing the helium together, and then fusing all the other elements as well. But just to be clear, they are still also fusing hydrogen at this stage. And then when they do the big firework (sorry, just can't get Douglas Adams out of my brain) they scatter all these various elements in all directions. Enough of this scattered matter is hydrogen that a new generation of stars can form. IIRC they think it actually takes several generations of dead stars to get the seriously heavy metals like the ones people hurl at each other on battlefields. Looks like you want to lean on the simplicity metaphor for what these stars are up to, by contrast with the messy organics happening elsewhere, on Earth. Getting into the details of the elemental abundance problem probably detracts from that, so I guess you probably don't really want to go there, so don't mind me if so :).

Are they named after the town in Italy? Or maybe Saint Joseph of Cupertino, the patron saint of students (he kept failing his entrance exams to join the Franciscans) and pilots (he was too simple-minded to know that humans can't levitate, so he did, reportedly). Or even the city in California where commercial real estate is almost impossible to get hold of due to the dominance of one company in particular :).

Expand full comment
8 more comments...

No posts