I was listening to the Bulwark podcast yesterday. Tim Miller chopping it up with Amanda Carpenter about Trump’s authoritarian project. Just some light chat to start the day.
Carpenter was taking her kid to a Weezer concert in Washington, D.C. and looking for advice from Miller about how a grown up even goes to a concert these days. Tim lobbed back the revelation that Weezer’s Blue album was the first CD he ever bought, and they digressed into a discussion of physical media, Amanda C revealing that the kids these days, by which I guess she meant her daughter and friends, are really getting into physical media. Apparently they’re collecting classic albums on CD, probably part of the pushback against online culture, streaming, and everything going digital.
Of course, CDs are digital media, but they’re also analogue because you got to have the atoms to make them work: the atoms in the CD, the atoms in the player. It all reminded me of the hundreds, maybe over a thousand, CDs I used to have and the hundreds of Blu-ray discs I kept alongside them. And how much I regret getting rid of them all.
I do remember why I got rid of them: they were pissing me off. We’d moved a couple of times before settling in the house we now live in, and boxing up 1,000+ discs every time we changed address, then unpacking them, shelving them, and boxing them again the next time we moved, meant that streaming arrived as a merciful release for me.
I can still recall how I felt when I got rid of those discs. It was giddy and vengeful with the intensity of wanting them out of my life, and now, of course, I look back and I think I’ve made a terrible mistake.
I still love the ability to stream music, but if I’m being honest, I just stream the same 200 or 300 songs over and over again, depending on which playlist I’ve got on:
- the songs I listen to when I’m exercising

- the songs I listen to when I’m driving

- the songs I listen to when I’m walking the dog

- some other songs I listen to when I’m cooking, and maybe some tunes I have on in the background at the end of the day while we’re having a drink, waiting for dinner
Honestly, it’s 200 or 300 songs over and over again. I just don’t have the time or the bandwidth, mentally, for streaming every fucking song in the world. Of course, there are times when you find that the song, or more likely the album, you really wanted to listen to isn’t available on streaming, and so you’re not gonna be able to listen to it. And do I really want to walk all the way across the room to physically insert a DVD into a machine like some sort of animal? No. No, I do not.
So, I dunno where I’m going with this recollection. I’m not about to try and rebuild my CD collection because I do remember the inconvenience and frustration of having to deal with all those boxes and all that filing. On the other hand, the kids aren’t wrong. There’s something to be said for holding the art in your hand.


I have a life hack for all you people. And that is to shack up with a borderline hoarder. Sure there are piles of crap everywhere that you just can't convince them to get rid of . . . . . but they do come in handy when some tech oligarch mega corp decide to convince you that you can just stream something and not have to lug around actual atoms and then take access away once you are hooked in. Or put in ads even if you were paying for the privilege of no ads in the beginning.
We've started listening to our CDs again for want of anything else. And there aren't any ads. And hell, we even started adding to an old record collection. Started going to gigs again and buy an LP as merch if its on offer.
The uni kid the other day sent me a text message out of the blue "what are some of Helmet's best songs?" Apparently they were all sitting around at 11.30 at night talking "old" music . . . . . after i got over the double shock that she asked me instead of google and the realisation that 90s Helmet was in fact "old", i said that you really need to listen to albums, as they were the experience back in the day. Not just one song or two. The album was the experience. 40-70min of amazement.
I am trying to be more thinky, not just in response to your posts but to everything in my life.
So I held off responding, clamping down the flash of concern that someone else would make the quote I wanted to use, identify the pithy observation I would have made if I went with my gut, etc.
I too remember ditching my CDs, DVDs & Blue Rays and occasionally feeling frustrated when something I wanted to watch was not available on streaming.
For music over the years I have been slowly buying songs through itunes, I never made the jump to music streaming. Unlike you I do not have a series of dedicated playlists so instead over the Christmas holiday period I compile a single playlist for the coming year for me to listen to, (adding any songs I buy that year to that playlist). I tend to only listen to music when I am driving too and from the airport to collect/drop off people. When I am out walking, up to the shops, or the library, or driving to work I listen to podcasts - so many podcasts.
But I recognise my experience is anachronistic, younger people are in a world where how I lived at their age does not exist so I am keen to see their solutions (fingers crossed it will involve extremely rich powerful men's heads spitted on pikes) - I admire their recognition of the utility of physical media I also read a claim many younger folk are increasing their reading of books more than watching short form media.
I love the idea of physical media being art you can hold in your hand.